An athlete is eligible for nomination to the Hall of Fame five years after the completion of his/her intercollegiate eligibility. They must have attended Greenville College or Greenville University for a minimum of two years.
| 1990 | Gary D. Beck |
| 1990 | James F. Staff |
| 1990 | Nora Koppen Schulze |
| 1990 | Shelby F. Young |
| 1991 | C. Loren Aandahl |
| 1991 | Jerry L. Arvin |
| 1991 | John J. Hammond |
| 1991 | Nancy J. Davenport |
| 1991 | William E. Cook |
| 1992 | Carolyn J. Parker |
| 1992 | David M. Johnson |
| 1992 | William D. Staff |
| 1993 | Arthur R. Bollinger |
| 1993 | Donald R. Brooks |
| 1993 | Ronald D. Shives |
| 1993 | Tammy S. Kline |
| 1994 | Floyd Staff |
| 1994 | Myra Wilkins |
| 1994 | Susan Pitol |
| 1996 | David E. Jack |
| 1996 | Lynn R. Carlson |
| 1996 | Tena M. Krause |
| 1998 | Bruce Bellen |
| 1998 | Diane Tabbert Jack |
| 1998 | Jarielle Harner Winkleman |
| 2000 | Betty Jane Shugart Fratzke |
| 2000 | Brian D. Martie |
| 2002 | Anthony E. Hubbard |
| 2002 | David E. Powell |
| 2002 | Jo Ann R. Noble |
| 2004 | Rachelle Minott Klopfenstein |
| 2004 | Richard H. Weinhandl |
| 2006 | Johhny E. Branch, Jr. |
| 2006 | Judith Arnold Fritz |
| 2008 | Lanny J. Conner |
| 2008 | Richard A. Boileau |
| 2008 | Wesley G. Porter |
| 2010 | Andrea Shultz Vogler |
| 2010 | Beth Lunte McFeron |
| 2010 | Lewis G. Carroll, Jr. |
| 2012 | Dan C. Cunningham |
| 2012 | Mark A. Theiss |
| 2012 | Thomas W. Young |
| 2014 | Donna Lay Collins |
| 2014 | Julie Kaufmann Shultz |
| 2016 | Martin D. Daily |
| 2016 | Craig A. Harper |
| 2016 | Meredith Deters Dust |
| 2016 | Natalie Lappe Goestenkors |
| 2018 | John L. Curry |
| 2018 | Richard L. Ware, Jr. |
| 2018 | Sonya L. Jones |
| 2018 | Christina Niehaus Blevins |
| 2021 | R. Colby Johnson |
| 2021 | Amy Brinkerhoff Aguilar |
| 2021 | Jessica Dothager Koele |
| 2022 | Jeff A. Boele |
| 2022 | Rodney S. Malone |
| 2022 | Stefan R. Neece |
